The ethical issues in the debate over human cloning

This childs cells have not yet been used in a cloning procedure. A ban on therapeutic cloning also would not prevent unsupervised researchers from going ahead with reproductive cloning efforts on their own [see Reproductive Cloning: Others worry about more remote dangers.

Young women are being paid substantial sums to provide eggs that can help single women or couples have children. To increase that to a number that can be used in research, she must be given stimulatory medications such as those used in reproductive IVF procedures.

Unfortunately, it can be very difficult to pin down precisely what any of these claims really mean in the context of bioethical debate.

Embryos normally do not attach to the wall of the uterus and begin development until after the blastocyst stage. And we set payment for participation at a modest level: The reward is assisting at the cutting edge of medical knowledge.

Thus cloning supposedly confronts us with a slippery slope to another slippery slope … which seems like a tenuous style of argument. Islam[ edit ] The prominent Qatari scholar Yusuf Al Qaradawi believes that cloning specific parts of the human body for medical purposes is not prohibited in Islambut cloning the whole human body would not be permitted under any circumstances.

Select a research area from the adjacent list Cloning Information: Cell donors, for example, might find themselves at the center of a media storm if they are identified as having allowed themselves to be cloned.

There is already evidence that some cloned animals can experience improper gene expression and disruptions in imprinting, the normal pattern of silencing genes not needed in particular tissues. Since then, the fear-mongering has partly died down, but not before a great deal of draconian legislation was enacted across the world.

We wanted to prevent payment from becoming an undue influence that could blind women to the risks. And if they can be paid for the time and discomfort that egg donation for reproductive purposes involves, why cant they receive reasonable payment for ovulation induction for research purposes?

We concluded that in general this is not advisable, because on reaching maturity the child may feel morally compromised by having been made to contribute to a cloning procedure. Some critics worry about a larger social effect, or even an effect on our species, if cloning restricted the diversity of children being born perhaps because parents and doctors might look for donors with a narrow range of characteristics, such as possessing high intelligence and meeting certain standards of physical beauty.

Thus, therapeutic cloning research could actually reduce the likelihood that cloning would be seen as a viable reproductive option. Are eggs any different? The key ethical issue with therapeutic cloning is the moral status of the cloned embryo, which is created solely for destruction. Clonaid claimed that it had a list of couples who were ready to have a cloned child.

In opposition to this, some people hail the prospect of cloning.

The Ethical Considerations

However, the early debate was very one-sided. They see it as a new way to provide biologically related offspring for some infertile couples or as a means of reducing the risks of some inherited genetic diseases. Like our board members, they argue that the benefits of this research and the possible therapies it could produce far outweigh the claims of the activated eggs.

Although therapeutic cloning could help scientists perfect techniques for reproductive cloning, it could also make much clearer the dangers of trying to produce a human being in this way. The White House was also critical of the claims.

Although it possesses some potential for developing into a full human being, this capacity is very limited. But issues relating to cloning technology remain crucial to debates over biomedical research and its regulation.

Such problems could discourage prospective parents from using this technology to have a baby. After researchers derive stem cells from cloned human activated eggs, ethicists will need to determine at what point it will be safe to try to transplant such cells back into volunteer donors.

Cloning can occur at the level of DNA, at the level of the single cell, or at the level of the whole organism. If a person can agree to undergo a dangerous malaria vaccine study to help cure disease, why should they be prevented from donating eggs for similar lifesaving research?

Although some ethical issues are raised with therapeutic cloning — including a concern that the associated research destroys human embryos — the idea has been obtaining legal acceptance in some countries, usually subject to tight government regulation. Allow me to explain.

Across the world, many countries banned human cloning - often with significant punishments, such as lengthy jail terms, even for attempting such a thing.

Some of those who think this way, however, might nonetheless find acceptable research on human stem cells derived from embryos left over from in vitro fertilization IVF procedures.The debate over cloning illustrates how complex innovations in biotechnology often outpace society's ability to make sense of them.

Ethics of cloning

According to the Pew Initiative on Food and Biotechnology, U.S. consumers know little about biotechnology but are more strongly opposed to cloning animals than they are to genetically modifying plants. The Ethical Considerations The need to obtain a supply of human eggs leads to one of the most sensitive ethical issues cloning research.

In each of her monthly cycles, a woman usually produces. - The Ethical Debate on Cloning In the article, “ Biotechnology, Ethics and the Politics of Cloning, ” the authors, Steven Best and Douglas Kellner describe the advantages and disadvantages of cloning and discuss the ethical issues related to cloning.

Ethical Debate On Human Cloning. Print Reference this. Published: 23rd March, because the process is far from being regarded as infallible, but it raises mostly moral and ethical objections that go well beyond issues of safety and scientific concerns.

For example, it took just over tests before the scientists can create the. Gearhart said concerns about human cloning are "overwrought," given that the scientific community is empathically not interested in crossing the ethical lines involved. Moral And Ethical Issues Of Human Cloning Philosophy Essay.

Print Reference advantages to it? But then again, a line has to be drawn somewhere, does it not? Before going into the controversial debate over cloning, a concrete, dictionary definition of what a clone is, must be given in order to prevent any confusion that may occur later on.

The ethical issues in the debate over human cloning
Rated 4/5 based on 71 review